Australian business groups say a Productivity Commission inquiry into business dynamism has overlooked some of the sector’s biggest concerns after Treasurer Jim Chalmers excluded tax settings and workplace relations from its scope.
The commission’s interim report, released on Friday, examined ways to help businesses start, grow and adapt. Its recommendations include changes to insolvency laws, simpler regulatory reporting and improved access to information about government requirements. But business representatives argue the inquiry could not properly assess the barriers facing companies without examining taxation and industrial relations.
Business groups criticise the inquiry’s scope
Andrew McKellar, chief executive of the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, said the topics examined by the commission were worthwhile, but the terms of reference were too narrow. He compared assessing business dynamism without considering tax and workplace relations to a medical examination that could not check a patient’s heart or lungs.
Business Council chief executive Bran Black also argued that tax and industrial relations were central to investment and productivity. The criticism comes amid strained relations between business groups and the Albanese government, particularly over proposed changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts and capital gains tax.
Trust tax proposal faces business opposition
The government plans to introduce a 30 per cent minimum tax on discretionary trusts, with the proposal expected to be debated during the final parliamentary sitting period of the year in mid-November. Business groups, including the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry and the Council of Small Business Organisations Australia, say trusts provide flexibility for small businesses and should not be subject to the proposed minimum rate.
The proposal includes an exemption for trusts that give up some discretion over how money is distributed. However, accounting and business representatives have argued that the exemption is too restrictive. Representatives from Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand have called for greater flexibility, including provisions that account for family breakdowns.
The debate is also being watched by the Greens, whose Senate votes may be important to the proposal’s passage. The ABC reported that tax academics who gave evidence to the inquiry have influenced the party’s thinking, although the Greens broadly support the proposal’s aims while retaining some concerns.
Start-up capital gains tax changes also questioned
The government has also proposed a carve-out that would allow qualifying investors in innovative start-ups to retain the existing 50 per cent capital gains tax discount instead of using the proposed inflation-based discount.
The change is intended to address concerns from founders that indexing the initial value of a new business could leave them with little or no discount when they sell, because a start-up may begin with a very low initial value.
Independent MP Allegra Spender supports offering start-ups an alternative but says the proposed carve-out is too complicated and narrowly targeted. She has called for a flat 40 per cent discount on active assets, which are assets used in operating a business.
The government has pointed to Treasury analysis suggesting the inflation-based approach would not always be less favourable than the existing discount. Treasury Secretary Jenny Wilkinson has also cited an OECD finding that capital gains tax rates are not a major determinant of a country’s level of innovation.
Productivity Commission identifies declining business dynamism
The commission’s interim report found that Australian businesses have become less dynamic, pointing to declines in the rates of businesses entering and leaving the market and in job mobility.
It said productivity growth depends partly on an economy’s ability to renew itself through the creation, expansion, restructuring and closure of businesses. While governments are not responsible for creating entrepreneurs, the commission said policy settings can influence the conditions in which businesses operate.
Among its interim recommendations are a “tell us once” approach to information businesses provide to government regulators and appointing an official liquidator as a last resort when a company cannot afford to fund its own liquidation.
The inquiry’s final direction will be watched closely by business groups as the government advances its trust tax and capital gains tax proposals. For now, the disagreement highlights a broader divide over which policy settings are most important to improving investment, innovation and productivity in Australia.
Source note: This article is an original news rewrite based on reporting by Tom Crowley for ABC News. Statements and policy positions are attributed to the individuals and organisations identified in the source report.
