Anthony Albanese is facing a difficult balancing act as his government considers how Australia should attract and regulate artificial intelligence while protecting the people whose creative work helps train the technology. The debate is testing a long-standing relationship between Labor and Australia’s music and wider creative communities, according to Peter Lewis.
In an opinion article published by Guardian Australia on 11 November 2026, Lewis argues that the Prime Minister’s personal connection with Australian music makes the copyright debate especially significant. Albanese has long been associated with Sydney’s inner-west music scene, and a photograph supplied with the article shows him at Red Eye Records in Sydney in 2018, when he was a Labor MP.
The immediate challenge is how to respond to major artificial intelligence investment proposals without weakening copyright protections. Lewis writes that AI company Anthropic is seeking to establish its model-training operations in Australia and has proposed renewable-powered data centres that could supply computing capacity to international markets. The article says the company is seeking a market valuation of US$1.5 trillion.
Supporters of the investment vision see an opportunity to develop a new export industry and give Australia a stronger position in the global AI supply chain. The government, Lewis writes, believes building a significant role in AI production could help the country capture economic benefits while retaining influence over how the technology is developed and used.
But creators and copyright advocates warn that many AI systems have been trained using books, music recordings, videos, news reports and academic work gathered without permission. They oppose proposals that would relax copyright rules or provide retrospective legal protection for the use of that material. Lewis describes the risk as turning Australia into a destination where the use of protected creative work could be legitimised after the fact.
For artists, the concern extends beyond the material used to train AI models. The technology can also generate work that imitates skills and styles developed by human creators over many years. Lewis argues that this raises questions about the value of original work, the ability of artists to earn a living and the place of human creativity in a rapidly automated economy.
The opinion piece places the copyright dispute within a wider set of concerns about artificial intelligence. Lewis points to questions raised by mathematicians about whether machine-generated answers can be properly understood, concerns among educators about students losing opportunities to develop their own skills, and worries among psychologists and therapists about relationships with chatbots. He also notes pressure from the energy and water demands of expanding data centres, alongside concerns about the inflationary effects of large technology investments.
Lewis argues that any settlement should give creators control over how their work is used and provide meaningful compensation. He also calls for clear labelling of AI-generated material, stronger promotion of human-created work and a way for artists and the wider community to share in the value produced by AI systems.
He suggests a broader cultural agreement between government and creative industries, drawing a comparison with the accord between the Hawke government and trade unions during an earlier period of economic change. The aim, in his view, should be to ensure that technological progress supports Australia’s cultural life rather than simply replacing the people who produce it.
The debate also comes as parts of Australia’s live music sector continue to face pressure. Lewis contrasts the established acts still performing at Sydney’s Enmore Theatre with the Sando, a venue where emerging bands once played and which has since become a mini-golf arcade and, more recently, a social darts club.
Lewis is non-executive chair of Essential, a strategic communications and research company that conducted qualitative research for Labor at the last federal election. He also hosts the weekly podcast Burning Platforms. His argument is that the government has an opportunity to shape the future of AI, but that protecting creative work must be part of that decision.
