Victorian Labor’s decision to leave voter preferences open in the Melbourne seat of Prahran has drawn a sharp rebuke from the Greens, whose leader says the move could help the Liberals and One Nation retain the seat and potentially influence who forms the next state government.
Ellen Sandell, the Victorian Greens leader, criticised Labor on Tuesday after the party confirmed it would ask voters to put its candidate, Meghan Hopper, first on the ballot but would not recommend how they should allocate their remaining preferences. Labor’s how-to-vote material is expected to leave the remaining preference boxes blank.
Prahran is an inner Melbourne electorate currently held by Liberal MP Rachel Westaway on a margin of 1.3 per cent. The Greens are seeking to win the seat back after losing it to Westaway at a 2025 byelection. Labor preferences could be important to that effort.
Sandell described Labor’s decision as “frankly unforgivable” and said it was inconsistent with the party’s warnings about the possibility of a Liberal-One Nation government. She argued that leaving preferences open could make it easier for the Liberal and One Nation candidates to hold the seat.
“After months of scaremongering about a Liberal-One Nation government, Labor is now using its preferences to help elect one,” Sandell said.
She also said the election result could come down to a single seat and that One Nation could hold the balance of power. Those comments reflect the Greens’ warning about the possible consequences of the preference decision, rather than an established election outcome.
The Greens’ position is shaped by the previous contest in Prahran. The party recorded a 13.4 per cent swing at the 2025 byelection, which was influenced by several factors, including Labor’s decision not to field a candidate, low voter turnout, a well-funded campaign urging voters to put the Greens last and preference flows from other candidates that were unfavourable to the party. Former Labor MP Tony Lupton also contested the byelection as an independent.
Labor is also running an open ticket in neighbouring Caulfield, where Liberal MP David Southwick holds the seat on a 2.1 per cent margin. The report said Southwick was expected to retain the electorate comfortably. It is understood local campaigns in Prahran and Caulfield requested the open-ticket arrangements.
A Labor spokesperson said the party’s message was to put a number one beside Labor candidates everywhere, adding that it was fighting for majority government. The approach is consistent with the position Labor took at the 2025 federal election in the overlapping seat of Macnamara.
The preference dispute comes as the Liberals and Nationals confirmed they would exchange preferences with One Nation at the state election. Opposition Leader Jess Wilson said Coalition how-to-vote cards would direct voters to place Labor, the Greens and the Victorian Socialists at the bottom, with other parties above them.
Separately, One Nation disendorsed its Preston candidate, Franco Guardiani, after tweets emerged including one that described Adolf Hitler as the “GOAT”. Liberal senator Jane Hume called the posts “vile” and said Guardiani would be placed last on the Coalition’s how-to-vote material in that electorate.
For Prahran, the immediate issue remains Labor’s decision not to direct preferences to the Greens. Sandell says that choice could have consequences beyond the local contest, while Labor says its priority is securing a majority government.
