A New South Wales coronial inquest is examining the deaths of four babies following free births or home births in the Northern Rivers region between 2022 and 2024, including the involvement of a self-described birth keeper in the care of two of the babies.
The inquest began at Lismore Local Court on Monday. The court will consider whether the care provided in the circumstances was reasonable, including the role of an unregistered support worker before, during and after birth.
The hearing was told that Sita Tara Kali, also known as Mumma Sita, advised the mother of Baby R to “go home and rest” after the woman had received urgent medical advice to attend an emergency department.
According to evidence outlined at the inquest, an ultrasound at 43 weeks showed the baby was extremely compromised. Obstetric advice was urgent, and the mother was strongly advised to attend hospital and not proceed with a home birth.
The mother had told police she distrusted hospitals and felt threatened by previous experiences there. She trusted Kali and believed a home birth would give her a stronger connection with her baby.
Kali said in a police statement that the woman was upset and anxious. She said she advised her to go home, rest, calm down and consider what she wanted to do.
Baby R was born at 9.51am outside the home, into his father’s hands. Two doulas were present, neither of whom had medical training. The baby was described as white in colour and did not latch on to feed.
An ambulance was called about 14 hours later. The umbilical cord and placenta were still attached. Baby R died at 12.22am while being transported towards a waiting helicopter.
The cause of death was recorded as unascertained. An expert neonatologist suggested it may have resulted from hypoxic-ischaemic encephalopathy associated with severe post-maturity.
Midwifery academic Professor Hannah Dahlen told the court the baby was one she would have monitored closely. She explained that a registered midwife’s clinical training provides the knowledge needed to interpret signs and symptoms and identify when a birth is not progressing normally.
Counsel assisting the inquest, Ragni Mathur, told the court that women may choose unregulated free birthing after traumatic or coercive experiences, fragmented care, a lack of trust in clinicians, limited access to services in regional NSW, or concerns involving child protection and regulatory action.
The inquest will examine the circumstances surrounding all four deaths. The evidence heard so far relates to Baby R and the care provided before and after the birth.
