Australia’s political leaders risk giving ground to populist movements if they continue to dismiss public frustration instead of listening to the concerns behind it, argues writer and academic Julianne Schultz.
In an opinion article published by Guardian Australia on 8 November, Schultz points to recent political developments in the United States as evidence that populism and authoritarian politics are not inevitable. She argues that a new generation of American Democrats offered voters an alternative by responding to genuine grievances and giving them a chance to reject division, chaos and the influence of big money.
Schultz says similar frustrations are evident in Australia, where public trust is weakening and cynicism about politics is growing. She argues that many people feel politicians speak in prepared talking points rather than engaging with the anxiety, disappointment and economic pressures affecting their lives.
She warns that simply acknowledging that people are struggling is not enough. Voters want their concerns to be heard and translated into practical action, rather than being told to wait while political leaders continue to make promises that do not match their experiences.
The article names One Nation leader Pauline Hanson and Coalition figure Angus Taylor as politicians who, in Schultz’s view, are appealing to public anger through rhetoric that promises retribution. She argues that this approach may connect with some voters in the short term but does not offer a credible answer to the complex problems involved in governing.
Schultz suggests that Hanson’s style can appear authentic to people who feel disconnected from established political institutions. She says some voters believe Hanson speaks like people they know and understands the inequalities they experience, even as questions remain about her ability to manage the responsibilities of government.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese may benefit from the current political climate, Schultz writes, but she cautions against assuming that conditions will remain favourable before the next federal election, expected in 2028. She points to the latest Democracy Index from the McKinnon Foundation and the Scanlon report as further warning signs about public confidence.
She also argues that the response to the Bondi shooting and the alleged attack on independent MP Helen Haines showed how quickly public grief and concern can be overtaken by political point-scoring, security debates and process-driven responses. Schultz says calls for social cohesion will have little effect if they are not accompanied by meaningful engagement with communities.
One of the central problems, she writes, is that elected representatives can become increasingly difficult for ordinary people to reach. Security procedures, tightly managed public appearances and brief encounters can create a barrier between politicians and the communities they represent. That distance makes it harder for uncomfortable or challenging views to reach those making decisions.
Schultz contrasts this with the community-based approach associated with former independent MP Cathy McGowan in the electorate of Indi. The model placed local engagement at the centre of political work and challenged the top-down approach often associated with party politics. She notes that many MPs and their staff still work closely with constituents, but argues that listening becomes more difficult as politicians move closer to the centre of power.
The article also points to former Queensland premier Peter Beattie as an example of a leader who responded to the need to listen more closely. After relying on the support of an independent MP, Beattie introduced cabinet meetings around the state accompanied by public forums, as well as monthly town-hall meetings where departmental heads answered questions and heard complaints and suggestions directly from residents.
Schultz says those meetings were unpopular with some senior public servants, but they brought government officials into direct contact with the experiences of the people affected by their decisions. The process, she argues, helped reshape policy by exposing decision-makers to views they might otherwise have missed.
Her broader argument is that representative democracy requires more than responding to the loudest voices or the interests with the greatest resources. It requires politicians to explain their decisions, acknowledge mistakes, weigh costs as well as benefits and remain accessible to the people they represent.
With trust in government under pressure, Schultz argues that rebuilding confidence must involve a two-way relationship: citizens need to feel heard, while those in power must also trust the communities they serve. For Australian leaders seeking to counter political division, she concludes, listening and responding to real grievances offers a stronger path than promising retribution.
