
The Albanese government will not adopt a proposal from Australia’s antisemitism envoy to abolish the ABC and SBS ombudsmen and replace them with an external oversight body.
Jillian Segal made the recommendation in an updated plan to combat antisemitism released last month. She proposed an “external independent ombudsman” to monitor the public broadcasters’ coverage of the war in Gaza and assess whether they meet their own standards for accuracy and impartiality.
Government sources have pointed to the Australian Communications and Media Authority (Acma), which already provides an independent avenue for complaints that go beyond the broadcasters’ internal processes.
Government points to existing media regulator
Segal argued that responsibilities held by the ABC and SBS ombudsmen could be transferred to an external body, drawing comparisons with oversight arrangements in sectors such as telecommunications and banking.
She said some members of the Jewish community remained concerned that coverage they viewed as one-directional could contribute to negative or hostile attitudes towards people who support Israel or sympathise with it.
However, government sources noted this week that Acma already acts as an external independent regulator and can investigate complaints escalated beyond the ABC and SBS ombudsmen.
A spokesperson for federal communications minister Anika Wells thanked Segal for her work and said there was no place for antisemitism in Australia. The spokesperson also said the government would continue working with the special envoy, the Jewish community and Australians more broadly.
Royal commission report expected in December
The government could consider further changes in response to recommendations from the Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion, which is expected to deliver its final report in mid-December.
The commission, led by former High Court judge Virginia Bell, was established after the antisemitic Bondi beach massacre in December 2025.
Segal’s proposal has drawn sharply different responses. Alex Ryvchin, co-chief executive of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, supported the idea of external accountability for public broadcaster coverage.
By contrast, the progressive Jewish Council of Australia described the plan as “Trumpian”, arguing that it threatened freedom of speech and democratic rights. The Australian Palestine Advocacy Network also criticised attempts to conflate legitimate criticism of Israel with antisemitism.
Broadcasters defend existing complaints processes
The ABC previously said its complaints process was the most robust and transparent in Australian media. Both the ABC and SBS have also pointed to their existing external review arrangements through Acma.
Segal has maintained that the independence of public broadcasters should be protected, while arguing that independence should not prevent external scrutiny of their reporting standards.
The ABC ombudsman has investigated public complaints about Middle East coverage, including reporting related to the Israeli president’s visit to Australia and an address by Israel’s ambassador to the National Press Club.
The debate over the proposal is likely to continue as the government considers the royal commission’s forthcoming findings and the role of existing media oversight arrangements.
Based on reporting by Tom McIlroy, The Guardian.
