Julia Gillard’s famous 2012 parliamentary speech on sexism and misogyny is back in the spotlight, with former prime minister Tony Abbott standing by his view that her attack on him was “over the top” and “unjustified”.
The speech, delivered in the House of Representatives on 9 October 2012, became one of the most widely remembered moments in Australian political history. It is being revisited by Gillard, Abbott and others who were present for an episode of the ABC program I Was Actually There, scheduled to air on Monday night. The speech has also been voted the most unforgettable Australian television moment.
A parliamentary clash that became a defining moment
Gillard was responding to Abbott, then Opposition Leader, during a heated parliamentary debate involving Peter Slipper, who was Speaker of the House at the time.
Slipper had left the Liberal Party to become Speaker, helping Gillard’s minority Labor government maintain its numbers in Parliament. His position had become increasingly difficult after allegations that he sexually harassed a staff member, James Ashby. Slipper denied the allegations, which were struck out in 2012. Ashby later successfully appealed that decision in the Federal Court, but subsequently dropped the case.
The controversy was dominating the political agenda. Abbott called for Slipper to be removed over text messages and argued that the government should have “died of shame”. The phrase echoed comments made by radio broadcaster Alan Jones about Gillard’s father after his death.
Gillard’s government was reliant on the support of independents to pass legislation, making the parliamentary numbers precarious. At the time, some journalists and politicians viewed the speech as an attempt to shift attention away from the Slipper controversy.
How Gillard prepared her response
Gillard has recalled that she and her staff gathered examples of Abbott’s previous comments about women and sexism as they considered how to respond to the criticism.
She said she had initially expected gender-based criticism to fade during her prime ministership. By October 2012, however, she felt it had become more intense. The remarks made during the parliamentary debate prompted what she described as a feeling of “cool anger”.
As she stood to speak, Gillard told Abbott: “I will not be lectured about sexism and misogyny by this man. I will not.” She went on to say the government would not accept such a lecture “not now, not ever”.
The speech was not fully scripted. Gillard’s recollection is that a selection of Abbott’s earlier remarks, assembled by her team, became part of her response in the chamber.
Abbott still rejects Gillard’s criticism
In the ABC program, Abbott said his relationship with Gillard had once involved mutual respect but had deteriorated before the speech.
He described her remarks as an “over the top and unjustified attack” and said he believed some of the accusations were unfair. Abbott also said he was not conscious of treating women differently because they were women or treating them as lesser.
Abbott maintains that Slipper’s resignation as Speaker the following day supported his position. He said it had been reasonable to argue that the government should feel ashamed of itself over the matter.
Gillard, meanwhile, recalled the speech as a response to what she saw as a pattern of gendered criticism, including remarks and public incidents involving Abbott during her time as prime minister.
The ABC retrospective revisits a parliamentary confrontation that moved well beyond the immediate dispute over the Speaker’s position. Gillard’s speech became an international talking point and a rallying cry for many women, while Abbott’s latest comments show that the two former political rivals continue to interpret the moment very differently.
