A federal circuit court has dismissed Ricardo Martins Silva’s claim against Toll Transport after finding he was sacked for using smartglasses to take photographs at a Victorian liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) terminal.
The case is believed to be the first reported instance in Australia of a worker being dismissed over the use of smartglasses in the workplace.
Martins Silva had worked for Toll for about eight months as an LPG tanker driver. He transported loaded tankers for Origin Energy from the Long Island Point terminal in Hastings, Victoria.
On 17 June 2025, he raised concerns with managers about a truck allocated to him, saying it vibrated excessively and was jumping. He was advised to use another truck. When he went to the terminal, he used his smartglasses to take photographs and sent them to a superior.
An Esso worker at the site told Toll that using electrical equipment at the terminal was inherently unsafe because an electrical spark could cause an explosion.
Toll stood Martins Silva down on 22 June while it investigated the incident. The company later treated the use of the glasses as a critical safety breach. He was suspended on 30 June, told on 9 July that the photographs breached the company’s code of practice and his employment contract, and dismissed on 18 July 2025.
Martins Silva argued that Toll had acted against him because he had raised complaints about truck allocations, safety and his working conditions, contrary to the Fair Work Act.
In a judgment delivered last week, Federal Circuit Court Justice Karl Blake found the smartglasses incident was objectively serious. The judgment said Martins Silva knew about the risks and had tried to reduce them by wearing safety glasses over the smartglasses. He also acknowledged during cross-examination that he knew he had done the wrong thing.
Martins Silva had told his employer that his judgement was affected by unresolved trauma from a truck fire in March 2025 in which he was injured. However, the court found he was dismissed because he wore the smartglasses at the terminal, not because he had made workplace complaints. His application was dismissed.
