Australian state governments could launch legal action against major tobacco companies in an effort to recover billions of dollars in publicly funded healthcare costs, under a proposal that estimates compensation claims could reach $50bn.
The proposal was developed by former barrister Neil Francey, who helped secure a landmark 1991 Federal Court ruling that established the evidence linking secondhand smoke to lung disease and respiratory conditions in non-smokers.
South Australia’s government is formally seeking advice on the plan, while other states are reviewing it. The proposal suggests the six state governments pool their resources and establish a joint legal taskforce to pursue the case in the Federal Court.
Proposal targets major tobacco companies
The proposed action would target the three dominant tobacco companies operating in Australia: British American Tobacco, Philip Morris and Imperial Brands, as well as their overseas parent corporations.
Francey argues the companies could be held liable under Australian consumer law for decades of misleading and deceptive conduct about the harms and addictiveness of smoking.
The plan seeks to recover healthcare costs incurred by the states since 2000, when internal tobacco industry documents were published showing the industry knew smoking caused serious diseases but had worked to obscure the evidence.
Francey said he believed a compensation figure of around $50bn could be justified, and potentially more. The proposal also envisages funding cancer screening programs and prevention measures.
The plan excludes the Northern Territory and the Australian Capital Territory. Francey said the territories are an arm of the Commonwealth and have different healthcare funding arrangements that could complicate the case.
South Australia seeks legal advice
South Australian Health Minister Blair Boyer said there was substantial public interest in measures that could reduce the burden tobacco-related diseases place on governments, health systems and communities.
Boyer said he had requested advice on the proposal, its likelihood of success and the potential benefits for South Australians before the government considers its options.
A spokesperson for NSW Health Minister Ryan Park said the state would review the proposal carefully. Queensland Health Minister Tim Nicholls had met with Francey, but the state said its current focus was on laws targeting the illicit tobacco and vape trade.
Western Australian Health Minister Meredith Hammat said the state was currently concentrating on strengthening tobacco legislation and enforcement.
Companies and experts weigh in
British American Tobacco Australia said it did not comment on potential or pending legal claims. Philip Morris and Imperial Brands did not respond to requests for comment.
Laura Hunter, chief executive of the Australian Council on Smoking & Health, said it was reasonable for tobacco companies to bear the costs of the harm caused by their products.
However, University of Sydney tobacco-control professor Becky Freeman said any legal action would need to be carefully planned and supported by a strong case, noting that litigation against tobacco companies overseas had taken many years.
Associate Professor Jonathan Liberman, a law and global health expert at the University of Melbourne, said successful litigation in Australia would require specific enabling legislation and well-resourced legal teams. He warned that without those foundations, proceedings could consume significant public resources and fail on procedural or funding grounds.
Earlier tobacco litigation provides precedent
The proposal follows major tobacco litigation overseas. In the United States, the 1998 Master Settlement Agreement saw major tobacco companies settle lawsuits brought by state attorneys general seeking to recover smoking-related healthcare costs.
In Canada, three of the largest tobacco companies were ordered in 2025 to pay billions in compensation for smoking-related harms. Health groups nevertheless expressed disappointment that the decision did not address harm from future tobacco use.
Francey’s earlier 1991 case in Australia was triggered by a Tobacco Institute of Australia advertisement claiming there was no scientific proof that cigarette smoke caused disease in non-smokers. The Federal Court found compelling scientific evidence that passive smoking caused lung disease and respiratory conditions, ruling the industry’s claims unlawful.
The latest proposal remains under consideration by state governments. No lawsuit has been filed under the plan, and governments are still assessing its legal prospects and potential costs.
Source: Melissa Davey, The Guardian, 12 November 2026.
