
Pressure is mounting on Treasurer Jim Chalmers to cut household clean energy subsidies in the federal government’s midyear budget update, with electric vehicle tax concessions and the cheaper home batteries program among the measures reportedly in Treasury’s sights.
But the debate over savings has raised questions about why household green energy support is attracting such urgent attention while other major areas of government spending, including nuclear-powered submarines and diesel fuel rebates for mining companies, receive less focus.
The cheaper home batteries program has offered households and businesses a taxpayer-backed rebate of 30% since July 2025. It has proved far more popular than initially expected. Treasury originally forecast one million new batteries by 2030 at a cost of $2.3bn. The latest estimate has risen to more than three times that amount, even after changes to the scheme.
Battery subsidy costs exceed forecasts
The original design of the program also made larger, more expensive batteries particularly attractive to buyers. A subsequent adjustment addressed that issue, and Treasury now estimates the scheme will cost $7.2bn.
The scale of the blowout has fuelled criticism that the rebate amounts to middle-class welfare. However, Alison Reeve, director of the energy and climate change program at the Grattan Institute, said the evidence for that characterisation was limited when the locations of installations were considered.
She pointed to households in outer suburban areas, including western Sydney, and regional communities as places where batteries were being installed.
Reeve argued that batteries would play an important role in Australia’s energy future and that support could help the industry develop until it became commercially self-sustaining. She also warned that cutting assistance could affect the network of small businesses, suppliers and tradespeople that had invested in the emerging home battery market.
EV tax concessions also under scrutiny
The electric vehicle subsidy, introduced in 2022, is also facing scrutiny. It exempts eligible workers from fringe benefits tax when they lease an electric vehicle through their employer. The concession has been more popular and more expensive than forecast.
Stephen Bartos, an economics professor at the University of Canberra and a former senior finance official, has criticised the tax breaks for electric vehicles. However, he argued that the case for public support for home batteries was stronger, because consumers were already shifting towards electric vehicles without the same level of assistance.
He said that if the government’s priority was reducing the budget deficit, green subsidies should not automatically be the first place to look. Their overall cost was relatively small compared with major spending areas such as health, the National Disability Insurance Scheme and defence.
Other major spending pressures in focus
The article highlights the scale of other government commitments. The National Disability Insurance Scheme was expected to cost almost $54bn in 2025–26. The Parliamentary Budget Office estimated in 2023 that acquiring nuclear-powered submarines under the AUKUS agreement could cost as much as $368bn over the life of the program.
The federal fuel tax credit scheme, which mainly benefits large mining companies, costs about $11bn a year and is rising quickly.
Bartos questioned why nuclear-powered submarines were largely absent from the public debate about potential budget cuts, given the scale of the commitment.
Political arguments over the budget
Opposition leader Angus Taylor has promised to abolish what he calls Labor’s “ideological climate bureaucracy” as part of $31bn in proposed budget savings over four years.
At the same time, the Albanese government’s proposal to introduce an income test for private health insurance rebates for people over 65 prompted strong criticism from the Coalition.
The debate over clean energy subsidies therefore sits within a broader political contest about which programs should be protected and which should contribute to budget savings.
How the battery scheme could be changed
Reeve said the home battery program could be redesigned to deliver more than a private benefit to individual households. One option would be to require subsidised batteries to support the electricity grid when demand is high.
She pointed to Western Australia’s approach, where households seeking a state subsidy had to connect their batteries to a virtual power plant operated by the network provider. That arrangement was designed to provide benefits across the wider electricity network.
Reeve also argued that the government needed to establish a clear pathway for eventually ending the subsidy, so its cost did not continue growing without control.
The central question for the midyear budget is whether savings should come from reducing household clean energy incentives, changing how those programs operate, or examining other major spending commitments.
Based on analysis by Patrick Commins, The Guardian.
